It was revealed shortly after the premiere of the original Breaking Amish that the cast had all previously abandoned their traditional lives before joining the show, and it appears that at least one cast member of the newest group has done the same.

Fans Not Looking Forward To New Season Of 'Breaking Amish?'

Vonda, who is one of the stars of the show's third season set in Brooklyn, N.Y., is being touted as a 29-year-old Amish woman from Indiana who has already committed to the faith through baptism and risks losing everything by leaving-but it appears that identity is false.

According to Starcasm, Vonda appeared to have actually left the faith as early back as 2003, when she was arrested and charged with resisting law enforcement-and in the mug shots the website found, she is clearly dressed in non-Amish attire-proving she may have left the faith long before then.

New 'Breaking Amish' Cast Thinks They'll 'Die' In Brooklyn?

In addition, the website found a large amount of racy Myspace photos that she featured in. One, a selfie, shows her in a dark space wearing a pink top and giving the camera a sultry look. A second features her looking to crawl across a floor while wearing white shorts and a brown bikini top.

Though these secrets aren't likely to be addressed when the show airs, TLC is teasing a secret that the star has in a character profile video.

"I have a really big secret that I keep from everyone," she says in a clip as she ties up her horse and buggy outside a house and walks around to the back, where she is let in by a man for a 15-minute session of some unspecified kind.

"There's so many rules with the church, it's just kind of hard to follow all of them," she says in the clip. "There's one thing I like to do for myself that nobody really has to know about."

She is then seen stripping off her clothes for the secret.

Breaking Amish season 3 premieres Thursday, September 18 at 10 p.m.

Tags
Breaking Amish, TLC, Reality TV