Amy Robach, T.J. Holmes’ Exes Pack On Steamy PDA While Ex-Anchors Admit Faking Happy Marriages

Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes' exes, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, were photographed packing on the PDA on the street.

In photos obtained by Page Six, Shue and Fiebig were spotted sharing a hug and a kiss as they said goodbye to each other in the streets of New York on Monday. The two were both wearing casual clothes -- a tie-dyed sundress and a pink jacket for Fiebig and a t-shirt and shorts for Shue.

Their sweet photos surfaced around six months after they reportedly started dating in December 2023.

Per Page Six, the two allegedly started dating because they shared and resonated with each other's traumatic experience of being cheated on by their former spouses, Amy and T.J.

"It turned to something else, and they're connected over their value," said a source before adding that being together helped the two "move on" from their ex-spouses' affair.

While reports said that the former "GMA3" hosts were still married to Andrew and Marilee when they started seeing each other, they claimed that both their marriages were already over at the time.

However, they were still fired by ABC for their "scandalous affair."

"After several productive conversations with Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes about different options, we all agreed it's best for everyone that they move on from ABC News," the company announced in a statement at the time.

Meanwhile, in the Monday episode of their "Amy and T.J." podcast, Robach and Holmes addressed the reports about their relationship, saying they were just faking happy marriages before.

Robach shared, "If there is only one episode of our podcast that people will ever listen to, we'd want it to be this one."

"We had very perfect-looking families and personal-looking lives. We were guilty of times of putting up an image of our lives that we knew was not true."

She revealed that she overcompensated with "picture-perfect" posts as her way of hiding the issues in her former marriage with Shue.

"I immediately was so afraid that anyone I knew would know or would think that something was wrong. I didn't want anyone to think anything was wrong. The problem is that everything was wrong. When I posted that picture, I was almost sure my marriage was over and yet I didn't want anyone to know. And no one did know for a while," she said.

T.J. also shared his side of the story, saying, "I moved out of my marital home in August 2022, and divorce was underway."

"I wouldn't wear it anywhere else. I would just go to the studio where I kept it and would put it on for the show. I didn't want anyone to know that I had another failed marriage," he added, saying he only wore his wedding ring for months on air to hide the reality between him and Fiebig.

Amy and T.J. then insisted that what they had was not an affair since they were already both single when they started to date.

Tags

Amy robach, T.J. Holmes