Toby Sheldon, also known as the Justin Bieber look-a-like, was found dead. Toby Sheldon, also known as the Justin Bieber look-a-like, was found dead. 'Botched' Star Kimber James Reveals 'The Most Painful Thing' She's Put Herself Through After he was reported missing on August 18th, TMZ announced that the Botched star was found in a Motel 6 in the San Fernando Valley on August 21.