They've appeared to have a happy marriage on their show, but things may not be quite as picture perfect as they have seemed between Rebecca and Abe Schmucker on Return to Amish.

Does Kate Have A Secret Boyfriend?

The couple, who married at the end of their first Breaking Amish season, may be headed for a rocky future, as an exclusive source has revealed that Rebecca may be cheating on her husband with his best friend, Mike Spencer.

Enstars has obtained footage from a private investigator showing Spencer at the couple's home with Rebecca and her daughters, just after 8 a.m., when Abe was out of town working his trucking job. Though the three pieces of footage appear to be innocent, the two seem a bit more familiar than friends, with Spencer going outside to get the mail and reading it, as Rebecca throws out the garbage. The two then leave in separate cars.



It is unclear how long the two have been close, but their relationship does seem to go back at least a couple of years. A photo on Mike's Facebook page from 2013 shows comments made by Rebecca where she says she misses him.


(Photo Credit: Facebook Screen Capture)

Even worse, it appears that Abe's family -- and the rest of the show's cast -- may already be aware that something is going on, with sources saying they have their suspicions, including Abe's mother, Mary.

Mary recently took to her Facebook page to share that she was going to leave the social media site again in an effort to focus on the Amish church, though a comment she made on a fan post seems to indicate she is staying off the site to keep herself from revealing a secret that needs to remain guarded, though it's unclear what the secret could be.


(Photo Credit: Facebook Screen Capture)

The news about Rebecca possibly being unfaithful to Abe isn't something surprising to fans of the TLC show, who have witnessed her questionable history.

Shortly after Breaking Amish aired its first season, it was revealed that Abe and Rebecca knew one another prior to filming and were already a couple beforehand, with a daughter. In addition, Rebecca was previously married to a man named Rufus Hostetler, with whom she allegedly filed for a marriage license in March of 2010, though she ran off with Abe and cheated on Rufus soon after, according to a post Hostetler put on his Facebook page.


(Photo Credit: Facebook Screen Capture)

Rebecca also slept with Abe's brother, Andrew, before coupling with Abe, creating speculation that her oldest daughter may actually be Andrew's.

Tags
Breaking Amish, Return to Amish, TLC, Reality TV